Vince Young's failings in the NFL are partly Mack Brown's fault
According to Yahoo Sports' Michael Silver, Vince Young's current struggles to adjust to life as an NFL quarterback are partly the fault of texas head coach Mack Brown.
Part of this is because, like many former Longhorns who played for notorious enabler Mack Brown (Cedric Benson, please pick up the burnt-orange-and-white courtesy phone), Young had an abrupt transition from his pampered collegiate existence to life in the NFL. Ask most NFL coaches which current collegiate program puts out the most spoiled stars and Brown, for a change, wouldn't have to beg for votes.
Ouch. Wonder if this "enabling" hurting NFL performance will be brought in recruiting by certain coaches at a certain institution North of the Red River?
To be fair, the media has glossed over many of Young's struggles while in college. Everyone seems to remember his magical run beginning after the Missouri game his sophomore year until the end of the national title game this junior season. No one remembers his struggles to fit in at QB at texas, and the calls from some fans for him to be moved to wide receiver. People forget that from the time he took the field as a backup in his redshirt freshman season in 2003 right up to and through that ugly win over Missouri in 2004, Vince Young was a mediocre college QB. His struggles now in the NFL aren't so different from his struggles then, although I don't think his current coaches in the NFL will coddle him like Greg Davis and Mack Brown did at texas.
0 recs |
7 comments
Comments
What a hack article
But the last line gives away his bias, he graduated from Cal.
Michael might want to let 2004 go, considering how his bears did against Tech in the holiday bowl.
by Wells on
Sep 14, 2008 5:12 PM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Michael Silver's sole purpose is to make other writers look better by comparision.
proud to swim home
by learned hand on
Sep 14, 2008 7:14 PM CDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
good point
I didn’t even consider the ramifications of his bias re: Cal Bears and the BCS in 2004.
You would think after the loss to Tech in the Holiday Bowl, they would have shut up.
by Beergut on
Sep 14, 2008 7:47 PM CDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Life in the NFL
Part of this is because, like many former Longhorns who played for notorious enabler Mack Brown (Cedric Benson, please pick up the burnt-orange-and-white courtesy phone), Young had an abrupt transition from his pampered collegiate existence to life in the NFL. Ask most NFL coaches which current collegiate program puts out the most spoiled stars and Brown, for a change, wouldn’t have to beg for votes.
It’s also because Young, for all his obvious leadership skills, is a sensitive dude with a penchant for pouting when things don’t go his way.
I thought this chunk was key to the article. Basically, he includes the first paragraph above to take a shot at Mack Brown because otherwise there isn’t enough meat in the article to make it interesting, and if you say nasty things about Mack Brown, someone will pay attention.
Then his second paragraph is really what the article is about.
And life in the NFL isn’t a pampered existence? WTF is that?
Let’s see… I go to college, I get a scholarship. I may or may not start. If I start, and I’m injured, my career could be over.
I go to the NFL. I get millions of dollars in guaranteed money (if a top draft pick). I will probably start because they paid me shitloads of money. If I’m injured, my career could be over….. but I’ve got a crapload of money!
Go Big Red Nebraska!
Our Cobs Are Bigger Than Yours!
Corn Nation!
by corn blight on
Sep 16, 2008 4:32 PM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
well, I wouldn't say it is a pampered existence
Consider that the average NFL career is less than 4 years long. So, if a kid comes out of college at 22, by age 26, he needs to stop defining himself as a football player (easier said than done, Brett Favre, hello?), and go find a real job.
Yes, the top draft picks get guaranteed millions via lucrative signing bonuses, but they also get the leeches and hanger-ons that go with that kind of money.
You also have to deal with the media in the NFL; Mack Brown isn’t there to answer questions for you or refuse interviews.
While I see your point, I do think either the writer is correct, and these guys were coddled too much in college, or Mack Brown did a helluva job hiding the fact that three of his star athletes (Williams, Benson, Young) all had insecurities/emotional problems/confidence issues.
by Beergut on
Sep 16, 2008 8:53 PM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs
helluva job hiding....
On the “helluva job hiding” thing… maybe Brown did, but the NFL spents a boatload of money trying to figure that stuff out ahead of time, right?
The background checks, tests, interviews, and then they still go ahead and draft a guy that had head issues because NFL coaches are arrogant enough to believe they can control or coach a guy out of his insecurities. That’s another area where you can look at this article and say that it’s easy to blame Mack Brown for the Titan’s problems. Kind of a cop-out, isn’t it?
Go Big Red Nebraska!
Our Cobs Are Bigger Than Yours!
Corn Nation!
by corn blight on
Sep 20, 2008 9:24 AM CDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs
well
one of my main criticisms of Brown is that I don’t think he lets some of his star players (his QBs in particular) face adversity and grow from it. I’m thinking more of Chris Simms than I am Vince in this regard, but I think it has hurt the development of his players ans his team. I think Simms in particular would have been a much better QB for texas had he been allowed to face adversity early on, and grow from it.
by Beergut on
Sep 21, 2008 12:18 AM CDT
reply
actions
0 recs









