“Winning an award – any award – does not prove anything; it’s evidence of a solid season, but proof that he is a top player, it is not.”
I always thought they presented these kinds of awards to the best – I was unaware it was only for a “solid” season. So the 4 Heisman finalists were really only there for their “solid” seasons – stupid me.
Your insinuation that I might be a retarded idiot may have some merit – I always thought the QB was the cornerstone to the team – like you have said of JJ and the aggys.

“Not to mention that a player’s "character" doesn’t make him talented at football. I’m a pretty good guy. Do I deserve a Heisman Trophy? Does being a good guy mean that nobody is free to criticize anything that I do?”
You DO understand the difference between character and talent do you not? Talent racks up statistics – character wins championships! As far as you are concerned, since you bring yourself up as a reference – have you ever QB’d an undefeated major college team? As a music major, I doubt it.
“It seems to me that stats are about the most objective way to look at something.”
How about this stat – 13 -0? By-the-way, Coach Boom says this is the only one that counts – anything else is for losers!

“You’d be a retarded idiot to think so.”, “You’re just being silly”, “Also, if you are a UT student or UT grad, why do you spend so much time on this blog and the OU one? Why don’t you just go to BON and call it a day?”
Attack me? Of course you haven’t!

You are right – I will vacate this blog and leave you alone – it’s obvious by your inane remarks that you can’t handle an opposing viewpoint!

i guess your forgetting that colt is from a town of 700 people! or the fact that he likes to fish and hunt with jordan shipley…….hmm i wonder how many people are from houston (jj’s home town)…….i bet he cant even hunt…(dont know how you can call hm a qb if he cant hunt)….so much for your argument that colt cant play unless he has stellar oline play….. my facts are hard and my truth is overwhelming

I had to address the hypocrisy of it. You chastised me for getting “personal” in my comments and stated that personal attacks are not approved.

I will be interested in seeing what you have to say to the little music major (future pants) about his personal attack on me. Although I think your football team is incredibly mediocre, I have always admired A&M’s traditions, for the most part, and their perceived sense of honor. We’ll put this to the test with your reply – if you have one!

“God you’re an idiot.” “But I DO think you’re retarded and being silly.”

For the year 2009 Colt was the second leading rusher – it was 2008 that he lead the team. Since this posting, Colt has made first team AP All America and Player of the year. Now, even if YOU don’t agree with this, the majority of knowledgable football people (including coaches) DO! So, your opinion flys in the face of people that have to make a living coaching football.

If I thought Sam Bradford was the better QB and even though my glasses are slightly tinted burnt orange, I would have said so. In 2008 Colt’s pass completion percentage was INCREDIBLE – above 76%. Now, you may say it was because of the spread system he was playing in – could be – however, Bradford played in the same systam as did 75% of the teams in the nation and THEY were nowhere near his stats. Finally, in a head to head game, and even though Bradford did well – Colt was the winning QB and, as coach Boom says, that is the only stat that really counts. So, my question to you is – where is YOUR objectivity?

You may say that it is hyperbole for me to suggest that Sherman would bench Colt in favor of Johnson – but I find it ludicrous to believe a coach (particularly one on the hot seat as most aggy coaches always seem to be) would bench the winningest QB in the history of college football in order to play your soph QB. Who is not being objective now?

But you are right about my bias – I am – and I certainly don’t agree that Johnson has performed better than McCoy. For one thing, Johnson hasn’t even played in a bowl game that presented the quality of competition that Colt has – mainly because they weren’t good enough to GET into that kind of game. When was the last time the aggys were in a BCS game?

Finally, for the ridiculous assertion, by that other aggy dude, that character doesn’t win championships – tell that to Bucky Richardson. Certainly he wasn’t the most talented QB when he played, but had the guts, will and character to not ACCEPT defeat and he jerked the Aggies up into a mindset they weren’t used to – that took CHARACTER!

As usual – Hook em!